How to choose an awesome property manager in 2022

One of the biggest benefits of being a passive real estate investor is that you can focus on growing your portfolio while delegating daily details such as property maintenance issues, rent collection, and tenant issues to someone else.

However, if you want the cash flow from your rental properties to stay strong and healthy, it’s important to understand how to choose the right property manager to handle your investments.

Key factors for choosing the right property manager

Choosing the wrong property manager for your specific type of investment property can lead to decreased cash flow due to high vacancy levels. For the same reason you want your potential tenants to be thoroughly screened, you want to put in the extra time and effort to find a great property manager. 

Key factors to look for when choosing a rental property manager include:

  • Communication by phone, email, or texts
  • Frequency of communication
  • How quickly and professionally the property manager responds to inquiries
  • Local experience with your specific type of rental property investment
  • Historical track record of filling vacancies at the fair market rent
  • Knowledge of basic accounting practices for income, tax, and real estate investment purposes
  • Technology and software used to organize and automate the property management process
  • How property manager fee structure compares to other companies in the same marketplace


What to expect from a property management company

Property management fees normally range between 8% and 12% of the gross rent collected. The money you pay your property manager takes a big bite out of your cash flow, so make sure that you’re getting your money’s worth.

Common tasks that a property management company performs include:

  • Property maintenance and repairs that keep the property in good operating condition
  • Property inspections including tenant move-in walk-throughs and move-out inspections, routine interior and exterior inspections, and drive-by inspections
  • Marketing vacant space for rent
  • Tenant screening and lease signing
  • Setting fair market rent and rent collection
  • Collect rent when due and make timely disbursements to the owner
  • Creating an operating budget in conjunction with the owner and managing the budget
  • Schedule and track the progress of maintenance requests
  • Handle tenant issues promptly when they arise
  • Manage finances and record-keeping, including payment of vendor invoices and providing monthly and annual operating statements to owner

How to find a great property manager

Not all property managers are created equal. Some specialize in single-family rentals, others in small multifamily properties. 

In larger metro areas, some property managers may only work in certain areas or with certain property classes such as brand new Class A homes, Class B workforce housing, or Class C cash cow rental property.

Here’s how to find a good property manager for you and your real estate business in six easy steps:

1. Ask for referrals

Reach out to your network and ask for referrals from several people. Good sources for property manager referrals include:

  • Fellow real estate investors
  • Real estate agents and brokers
  • Real estate attorneys
  • Mortgage brokers
  • Escrow companies
  • Contractors such as HVAC and landscaping companies


2. Review property management companies online

If you’re just beginning to invest in real estate long-distance you may still be building your local real estate team. Fortunately, there are several ways to research property managers online:

  • Internet search for “residential property manager” + your city name
  • Yelp and Better Business Bureau for ratings, customer, and client reviews
  • Craigslist ads for property managers advertising their services
  • Roofstock for vetted property managers with ongoing performance monitoring


3. Follow a standard interview process

It’s important to interview several property managers as part of your initial interview process. Key questions to ask when interviewing a real estate property manager include:

  • Years in business
  • Size of staff including full-time and part-time workers
  • Number of properties currently under management the current and previous year
  • Average length of time current clients have been with the property management company
  • Areas of the city the properties are located in
  • Average percentage of vacant properties at any given time
  • How the property manager determines fair market rents
  • Process for finding and qualifying tenants
  • Frequency of property management inspections and owner reports
  • How and when owner distributions are made
  • Online systems such as owner portal, tenant rent payments, and repair requests
  • Other services offered such as leasing and brokerage, and if the property managers has a dedicated staff for these extra tasks
  • Availability of in-house repair people
  • Education, training, and licensing of property management staff
  • Background of the property management company owners
  • Awards and other recognition within the local community


4. Verify certifications and licenses

Property managers in most states are required to have a real estate license and a general business license. You can verify that the licenses are active and in good standing by checking with the Department of Real Estate and Secretary of State offices.

Other common credentials a property manager may have include:

  • IREM – Institute of Real Estate Management
  • CAI – Community Association Institute
  • NAA – National Apartment Association
  • NARPM – National Association of Residential Property Managers


5. Understand your property management contract

A property management agreement is a legally binding contract between you and the property management company. The general terms and conditions of a property management agreement are based on state law and regulations from the department of real estate.

Key terms to look for when you review a property management contract include:

  • Beginning and ending date of property management agreement
  • Compensation structure such as fixed fee versus percentage of revenue, leasing fees, and new account start-up fees
  • Charges for extra services such as overseeing major remodeling and tenant evictions
  • Frequency of financial reporting and communication
  • Timing of owner disbursements after rent has been collected and operating expenses paid
  • Owner responsibilities including maintaining a reserve account and obtaining adequate insurance coverage
  • Owner restrictions including finding tenants, entering the property without notice, and listing the property for sale without informing the property manager
  • Agreement to abide by local, state, and federal fair housing laws
  • Insurance carried by property manager should include errors and omissions coverage and general liability insurance.
  • Property manager liability, “hold harmless” clause, and a “reasonable care” clause indicating the manager will take reasonable care when hiring third-party contractors
  • Automatic renewal clause and how much notice must be given 
  • Early termination clause including how much notice must be given, fee for ending the contract early, and obligations upon termination such as providing copies of all tenant leases and returning funds to owner


6. Ask for references

The final step in choosing a property manager for your rental property is to ask for references and samples of their work:

  • Speak with current clients of the property manager who own property similar to yours to see what they like and if there are any areas the manager could improve in.
  • Have one of your team members drive by several of the properties the company manages, looking for red flags such as numerous “For rent” signs and obvious signs of disrepair.



Benefits of hiring a professional property manager

When you were younger, you may have had a car you tinkered with and did DIY repairs on. But as you got older, two things happened: You found you had better and more profitable things to do with your time, and at the same time cars became increasingly more complex.

Rental real estate works the same way. To be fair, there are some do-it-yourself investors out there. However, today they’re more the exception than the rule. 

Part of the reason that most rental property investors choose a professional property management company is because real estate prices have been consistently rising in value. 

In fact, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, median inflation-adjusted home values have more than quadrupled since 1940 (the year the housing census began). Income-producing real estate is a major investment, and there’s simply too much risk in trying to manage the asset yourself. 

Managing your own rental property can also be incredibly complex, although at first glance it may not seem that way. Many investors find they quickly become overwhelmed by common property management tasks, or don’t have the interpersonal skills needed to deal with tenants. 

The most successful real estate investors find that their time is much more valuable than the cost of hiring a great property manager who knows and understands the nuances of the local real estate market. 

Key benefits of hiring a property manager include:

  • Make better use of your time by not having to deal with tenant drama or emergency repairs.
  • Avoid unintentional violation of local landlord-tenant laws by hiring a good manager who knows the local regulations.
  • Maintain control of your investment while delegating the daily details to your local pro.
  • Become a long-distance real estate investor in smaller secondary markets with higher yields and bigger returns.



Click me
This article, and the Roofstock Blog in general, is intended for informational and educational purposes only, and is not investment, tax, financial planning, legal, or real estate advice. Roofstock is not your advisor or agent. Please consult your own experts for advice in these areas. Although Roofstock provides information it believes to be accurate, Roofstock makes no representations or warranties about the accuracy or completeness of the information contained on this blog.
Jeff Rohde


Jeff Rohde

Jeff has over 25 years of experience in all segments of the real estate industry including investing, brokerage, residential, commercial, and property management. While his real estate business runs on autopilot, he writes articles to help other investors grow and manage their real estate portfolios.

Join 100,000+ Fellow Investors.

Subscribe to get our top real estate investing content.

Subscribe Here!