5 Expert Tips on How to Choose an Excellent Property Manager

Your rental property is an asset that requires proactive and professional management to protect it properly. You wouldn’t let your neighbor's friend manage your stock portfolio (unless, of course, she’s an actual portfolio manager). Likewise, your property demands a licensed, experienced investment property manager who is responsive and transparent.

Choosing the right investment property manager can be an overwhelming task, especially if you’re a first-time landlord. What qualifications should you be looking for? How do you sort the subpar investment property managers from the ones who will protect your investment as if it were their own?

At Roofstock, we eliminate much of this guesswork for you by thoroughly vetting all of our property managers before certifying them as one of our preferred partnersWe'll set you up with a local, preferred investment property manager, and continue to work on your behalf to ensure everything goes smoothly.

Alternatively, if you're searching for an investment property manageryourself, knowing what questions to ask is a great place to start.

With that in mind, we gathered pro tips on how to choose a great investment property manager from three experts: Mike Nelson of Excalibur Homes, Chuck Thompson of Specialized Property Management, and Chandler Janger of Suncoast Property Management.

Here are five key ways to tell if an investment property manager is right for you, plus helpful questions to ask:

1. Look for specialized experience

Property management is a complex industry. You want an investment property manager who is on top of current federal, state, and local laws. And you want someone who has a proven record of effectively handling the many variables that come with tenants and homes.

Look for a property management company with extensive experience caring for your particular type of investment. Companies that focus on commercial properties, for example, may not be equipped to properly manage residential properties. 

Last, avoid real estate agents who moonlight as property managers to earn extra money on the side. If they haven’t acquired specialized training, they won’t know how to tend to your investment properly and they’re less likely to be up to date on relevant laws and codes. 

Questions to ask:

  • How long have you managed rental homes?
  • How many rental homes do you currently manage?

2. Verify professional licenses and certifications

In some areas, you might find people managing properties with only a real estate license, and a few states don’t require a license of any type. Competent property managers and management companies should be able to back up their technical expertise with proper licensing and professional certifications. Check with your state’s real estate commission to see if a property manager’s real estate broker's license is current. Any professional affiliations and certifications are a plus. 

There are a number of trade organizations that offer certifications upon completion of rigorous training programs, exams, and portfolio and reference reviews:

Questions to ask:

  • Do you have a broker’s license?
  • What additional training and certifications have you received?
  • What certifications does the company have?

3. Check reviews and references

It almost goes without saying these days, but before you take time to meet with a property management company, read through its Yelp and Google reviews as well as the comments on its Facebook page. As always with these websites, keep in mind that some reviewers (say, an evicted tenant) may have an ax to grind that has no bearing on the quality of the company’s work. However, review sites can be a great first-line resource when comparing multiple companies.

It’s also a good idea to check with more traditional sources, such as the Better Business Bureau and Chamber of Commerce, for any complaints or positive affirmation.

References can be a helpful way to assess whether you’re going to have a positive relationship with the property mangagement company.

When speaking to a potential investment property manager, ask for current client and tenant references, if available. Pick up the phone and talk to both groups about their experiences. Does the property manager promptly respond to owner inquiries? Are they proactive when it comes to maintenance issues and filling vacancies? Are their fees clear and transparent? Do checks arrive on time?

On the tenant reference side: Is the house well maintained? Are their repair requests addressed quickly? Do they plan on signing a new lease? Happy tenants are more likely to remain in the property, which reduces vacancy days and keeps rent checks flowing into your account.

4. Examine the property management agreement

The property management agreement outlines the business relationship between you and the property manager, and delineates the management team’s tasks and responsibilities. Given the seriousness of the contract, it’s incumbent upon you to read it carefully and make any necessary amendments before signing off. Confirm that it covers everything you want, and that there are no disagreeable clauses.

Typically, the property management agreement covers:

  • Services provided and fees: Typical services include resolving tenant needs and requests, maintenance of the home, marketing and filling vacancies, collecting rent, handling move-outs and evictions, and all other daily operational duties. To avoid any billing surprises down the road, all fees—as well as the process for approving any additional expenses—should be transparently outlined in the agreement. Make sure the contract stipulates how repairs are handled and expensed, including a set expense limit that you feel comfortable with.

  • Owner responsibilities: In addition to laying out the manager’s responsibilities, the agreement may cover your responsibilities as well. Keep in mind: If there are any tasks you don’t want to perform, discuss these and assign them to your property manager.

  • Contract duration and termination clauses: The agreement’s tenure should have a specific start and end date. Often, they’re signed on a one-year basis. It’s also important for the agreement to cover breach of contract rules as well as termination fees and timelines.

5. Make sure they have the appropriate insurance

When we vet our Roofstock-preferred property managers, we confirm that they have appropriate general liability insurance, property casualty insurance, and errors and omissions (E&O) policies. Your property management agreement may also mandate that you have sufficient insurance, which is beneficial protection for you, too. Feel free to ask your property manager more about necessary insurance protection.

how to choose a property manager


Thoroughly evaluating potential property managers is important, which is why Roofstock performs extensive due diligence when vetting its preferred, best-in-class providers for property management. We examine historical portfolio performance, fee structure, length of time in business, and much more.

Either way: Whether you're using one of our preferred property managers or choosing your own, we hope the information outlined in this article will help you feel confident with your decision, knowing your investment is in good hands.

New Call-to-action


Meet our panel of property managers:

Mike Nelson is the managing broker of Excalibur Homes, LLC (CRMC), which is one of a handful of companies across the country to receive the Preferred Residential Management Company (CRMC) designation. Excalibur represents about 1,300 rental homes in the Metro Atlanta area.

He also teaches property management and real estate investing for the Georgia Association of Realtors and the Georgia Real Estate Commission selected him to serve on their Education Advisory Committee to represent the property management industry. He has a degree in real estate from the University of Georgia, is a licensed broker, has the Graduate, REALTOR® Institute designation from National Association of Realtors, along with the Residential Management Professional and Master Property Manager designations from National Association of Residential Property Managers.

Chandler Janger is the investor relations, marketing, leasing & sales manager at Suncoast Property Management. Suncoast is a full-service real estate firm, currently managing more than 1,700 properties. They are licensed in both Florida (where they actively service properties from Palm Coast to Nassau County) and Georgia.

Charles Thompson is Specialized Property Management’s CEO. For more than 30 years, Texas rental property owners have trusted Specialized Property Management to help their rental home investments be more profitable and avoid costly mistakes. Their full services include marketing, leasing, applicant screening, showings, rent-ready services, maintenance, managing tenant needs, rent collection, lease enforcement, and owner reporting and trust accounting. The firm maintains the highest online and customer satisfaction ratings in the industry.

Charles Thompson has over 25 years of experience specializing in turnaround management, strategy-based consulting, and implementing best-practice operational models within industry-leading brands. He is the president of CTX Legacy Ventures, which owns Texas-based Specialized Property Management and heads the firm’s long-term strategic direction, executive management, and ongoing company acquisitions.

Click me
This article, and the Roofstock Blog in general, is intended for informational and educational purposes only, and is not investment, tax, financial planning, legal, or real estate advice. Roofstock is not your advisor or agent. Please consult your own experts for advice in these areas. Although Roofstock provides information it believes to be accurate, Roofstock makes no representations or warranties about the accuracy or completeness of the information contained on this blog.
April Kilcrease


April Kilcrease

April Kilcrease is an Oakland-based writer and editor. Her work has appeared in the New York Times, the Guardian, and Interior Design. She loves wandering through open houses and nerding out over floor plans.

Join 100,000+ Fellow Investors.

Subscribe to get our top real estate investing content.

Subscribe Here!